bto solicitors - Corporate & Commercial Business Lawyers Glasgow Edinburgh Scotland

  • "really fights your corner..."
    "really fights your corner..." Chambers UK
  • "Consistently high-quality work and client-friendly approach."
    "Consistently high-quality work and client-friendly approach." Chambers UK

No port in a storm – the end for Safe Harbour

07 October 2015

The US government website (i) where American companies can register to self-certify under the safe harbour scheme looks exactly the same today as it did before the Schrems Decision, but the decision issued yesterday has swept away the very foundations of that scheme invalidating EU US data sharing arrangements founded upon it.

The US Department of Commerce reacted to the decision later yesterday with the following comment:

Paul Motion
Paul Motion, Partner

“We are deeply disappointed in today’s decision from the European Court of Justice, which creates significant uncertainty for both U.S. and EU companies and consumers, and puts at risk the thriving transatlantic digital economy. Among other things, the decision does not credit the benefits to privacy and growth that have been afforded by this Framework over the last 15 years.”

The American reaction is hardly surprising given that the CJEU decision, (which followed Advocate General Bot’s opinion, see our earlier blog), is not a good news story, particularly for American companies who are now firmly shut out from the European Data Protection regime.

The decision will impact heavily upon all organisations that are structured around international data flows and sharing arrangements between the EU and the US. Snowden’s revelations may have started the ball rolling by highlighting the vulnerability of data on US servers, but it is only now 2 years later that we are seeing the practical fall out.

Companies that use the Safe Harbour should take steps now to review their data transfer arrangements.

Wide reporting of the Schrem’s decision and the involvement of Facebook are likely to ensure maximum publicity for the decision. Data Subjects will be well aware of the impact of this decision upon the processing of their data. This means they are more likely than ever to question where their data is stored and potentially report their concerns. National Data Protection Authorities now have a new mandate to investigate EU US transfers and to question the decisions of the Commission. These authorities will not however have any more resources in the short term with which to carry out that task, a factor which may restrict substantially their ability to enforce the European Court’s decision.

The result is greater uncertainty with companies having to turn to alternative arrangements either in the form of self-certification of adequacy (a decision few data controllers will feel comfortable making), or placing reliance upon adequate safeguards. Adequate safeguards include the use of Standard Contractual Clauses or for larger organisations, Binding Corporate Rules approved by the European Commission for intra-group transfers. All of this will be costly and difficult for firms to implement.

As companies come under pressure to ensure their arrangements are adequate, they in turn are likely to place considerable pressure upon National Data Protection Authorities, who will respond with different approaches. The regulatory framework for data transfer will become considerably more difficult to navigate, representing a set-back for international trade and commerce.

The CJEU decision also raises the possibility of National Authorities questioning Commission decisions, raising the possibility of further scope for confusion and disagreement about national approaches to Data Protection Regulation.

For further information please contact Paul Motion on T: 0131 222 2939 or email us at

Read more blogs from the Data Protection Defence Team.



“The level of service has always been excellent, with properly experienced solicitors dealing with appropriate cases" Legal 500

Contact BTO


  • 48 St. Vincent Street
  • Glasgow
  • G2 5HS
  • T:+44 (0)141 221 8012
  • F:+44 (0)141 221 7803


  • One Edinburgh Quay
  • Edinburgh
  • EH3 9QG
  • T:+44 (0)131 222 2939
  • F:+44 (0)131 222 2949